While in New York visiting family, we tested out several different ice cream stands. Prior to this I had always considered ice cream to be pretty similar, only to find out I was quite wrong. Most of the ice cream stands in that area of New York were either Perry's or Hershey's - both delicious for different reasons. My favorite in the end was Boxcar Barney's, which happened to be the first one we tried. It was just too tasty.
The Winner: BROWNIE BATTER and COCONUT, ALMOND & CHOCOLATE. The flavors were amazing and the whole experience was just fantastic.
My second favorite was The Ice Cream Shack. I got Death by Chocolate and Chocolate Chip Cookie dough. The flavors were great, the consistency was nice and smooth and the ice cream was nice and hard.

Bemus Point had great flavor choices but it seems like they had difficulty keeping their ice cream cold, which is kinda important. I got white lightening (chocolate with thick ribbons of mint) and cannoli which was overpowered by the mint chocolate but very tasty.
Our last place ice cream stand is:
Big Tree was probably my least favorite, the flavor wasn't all that great. I got Eskimo Kisses which just didn't measure up to the other flavors I tried.
If I ever get back to Jamestown, I know where I'll be headed back to!